Sunday, April 5, 2015

Sheriff: No outside investigation needed

Sheriff: No outside investigation needed
compiling cost analysis of free surplus equipment program

By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

WARREN ä Trumbull County Sheriff Tom Altiere said he will not be asking another law enforcement agency to conduct an external investigation into alleged misuse of equipment acquired mostly for free in a federal surplus program.
The program allows law enforcement agencies across the country to browse through items government no longer needs, that have already been paid for with federal tax dollars, and select equipment they can justify a need for. Law enforcement agencies need only to pay the cost to transport items like trucks, guns, cold weather clothing, ATVs, boats, tools and bucket trucks from military bases in the region. The office has estimated the value of the free stuff at $2 million.
Altiere said Major Tom Stewartás internal investigation, in addition to uncovering any wrong doing, will oversee a financial analysis of the program and perhaps create a database detailing the state of the equipment. Some have criticized the sheriffás acquisition of vehicles that do not work, but maintenance workers are allowed to, under the program, use parts from other free tools and trucks to fix the items.
Craig Batzer is the Columbus liaison in charge of the monitoring the program for the Ohio Department of Public Safety, he conducted a surprise audit on the sheriff's office use, storage and record keeping of free stuff in August.
His audit uncovered no wrongdoing from the programás perspective.
âWhile there are certain qualifications used to regulate the distribution of the equipment, the discretion of the use of it is up to the department that signs for it,ã Batzer said.
His office does not have the authority to launch an investigation, although another audit has been scheduled for this month, at the request of the sheriffás office.
Warren council member John Brown, D-3rd Ward, said he accompanied deputy Ty Kata, the man who has led the officeás acquisition of about 1,000 items, on a trip to pick up numerous vehicles in a late January trip.
Brown said he, Zachary Svette, operations director of Trumbull County MetroParks, Kata and another deputy left for the Navy base in Norfolk, Va. at 9:30 p.m. to pick up four trucks and an ATV. They traveled all night, Brown said, and stopped only to get the vehicles and eat a fast food lunch, even though a blizzard was raging on the way back.
âI said, hey, Kata, lets stop and get a hotel, it is really coming down out there,ã Brown said. âBut Kata said, àno, we gotta get back.á He was all business.ã
The group returned at 9:30 p.m. the next night, Brown said.
Altiere said that if Stewartás investigation turns up any fishy activity on Kataás part, âhe will receive an appropriate punishment for it, just like anyone else would.ã
Stewart was off sick last week, but, Altiere said, if Stewart is uncomfortable with any aspect of the program, he will invite an outside look.
Altiere said he will make a list of any other deputies that went on the 44 trips since 2011, to pickup equipment and how much money those trips cost; including labor, fuel, tolls, food and even the associated costs to repair some stuff they received that wasnát in working condition.
When asked if the sheriff plans to keep Humvees that no longer have much of a use, because the department now has many all wheel drive vehicles, Altiere said he is considering transfering two or three of the four to the Meigs County Sheriffás Office, but wants to keep at least one.
âWe donát use our guns everyday, and we pray we donát have to,ã Altiere said.
Altiere said deputies have to practice using equipment they havenát used before, and that is an acceptable use of the items.
Kata has admitted to working on a construction vehicle at his farm, something Batzer said is perfectly alright with his office.
Altiere said some of the construction equipment would have been nice to have around back in the 90s when they had to exhume bodies, âIt would have saved us a lot of time if weád had that to use.ã
Now, the backhoe and other construction vehicles will be used to help clean up environmental crimes.
âWe just had someone dump a huge pile of tires over on Griswold Avenue,ã Altiere said. âWe will use some surplus items to help in that pickupã
Some trucks, Kata said, are used as undercover vehicles by the TAG Law Enforcement Task Force, formed by Altiere and the Mahoning County Sheriffás Office in 2001.
Batzer said the office can use the equipment any way it wants to, throughout the county, as long as they retain ownership and storage records.

rfox@tribtoday.com


Heroin overdoses in Trumbull


By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

WARREN ä The number of suspected heroin overdoses over a six day period in the county increased to eight over the weekend, county coroner Dr. Humphrey Germaniuk said Monday.
The problem is apparent in Trumbull Countyás biggest municipality, Warren, where there were four arrests for heroin possession between April 3 and 5. There were no arrests for trafficking in heroin.
Also in Warren, there was at least one suspected heroin overdose that led to the death of a 32-year-old York Avenue man, according to police records.
âThere was a strong suspicion of heroin overdose in this case and other cases,ã Germaniuk said. âBut we will not know for sure until the results of a tox(icology) screen come back in eight weeks.ã
Clint Beaver was discovered by his father, who told police his son, âis a known heroin addict and he knew this day was coming.ã
Germaniuk said sometimes family members sanitize the area surrounding the place a loved one died of a drug overdose, removing evidence to preserve the memory of the deceased. Sometimes police donát know a death was a result of a drug overdose.
But, when they do, law enforcement officials are asking police in all area departments to investigate the scene like any other crime, tracking down evidence and determining where the fatal dose came from.
The fatality associated with the heroin problem in the city may be exacerbated by the fact that city police do not carry Narcan, an antidote to opiate overdoses.
âWe want to provide our officers with Narcan,ã Chief Eric Merkel said. âBecause of its high cost, we may only be able to get it into the hands of supervisors.ã
Germaniuk said that for every body that comes to the morgue after an overdose, four to six people are treated for an overdose that he or she survives.
Jeffery Orr of the Trumbull Ashtabula Group Law Enforcement Task Force said a Monday meeting on the topic was closed and used to discuss undercover tactics, but that area law enforcement agencies will be coming together soon to help plan tactics to quell the epidemic of heroin use in the area.
âThere are a lot of methods we are using in TAG that I think some departments arenát aware or havenát been taking advantage of,ã Orr said. âWe want to share that information.ã
Orr said when his task force becomes aware that heroin is being sold out of a house, it is only ethical to allow it to stay open for a couple of weeks to collect evidence of drug trafficking.
Waiting more than a month to raid the house, while allowing police to collect more evidence for court, can lead to overdoses, Orr said.
Orr said the task force would gladly welcome the city of Warrenás participation in TAG effforts, and welcomes the department to consider rejoining the task force. The police department created a street crime unit a few years ago, removing its representative from TAG.
âIf we are overwhelmed by the issue, and we are, the city has to be worse off,ã Orr said. âWe have more resources, officers and money, to combat the problem.ã
In Trumbull County Common Pleas Court last week, there were six indictments for heroin possession and six for possession of other drugs or paraphernalia, there were 30 indictments total. Those charged individuals are due to be arraingned Thursday. There were no indictments in that court for trafficking drugs.
rfox@tribtoday.com

Thursday, April 2, 2015

Police Taser man with warrants in Md, find stolen guns

Police Taser man with warrants in Md, find stolen guns
By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

WARREN ä A man from Maryland who was shot with a Taser by police Wednesday night, is scheduled to be arraigned today in Warren Municipal Court on three felony charges and a misdemeanor, according to a police report and court documents.
Ernest Ojahrashod Williams is being held in the Trumbull County Jail and may also face extradition to Maryland for three felony theft offenses.
In Warren, Williams is charged with two felony counts of carrying a concealed weapon, one count of having weapons under disability and misdemeanor resisting arrest.
Officer Zachary Jones pulled over the vehicle Williams was a passenger in around 11 p.m. for speeding near the intersections of Austin Avenue S.W. and Palmyra Road S.W., a police report states.
When asked for his identification, Jones wrote that he became suspicious of the way Williams seemed to be hiding his face. Discovering Williams had warrants out for his arrest in Maryland, Jones said he asked Williams to step out of the vehicle.
âGo! Go! You gotta go! Just drive,ã Williams said to the driver of the car as he grabbed the gear shifter, according to Jonesá report.
Jones stated he reached across the driver, as she cried, and removed the keys from the ignition. As officers ordered him out of the car, Williams kept trying to grab the gear shift, saying, âI canát go to prison,ã the report states.
Williamsá shirt was ripped as Jones tried to grab him and remove him from the car. Jones yelled, âTaser, Taser,ã and aimed at Williamsá back, firing the Taser prongs into Williamsá jacket.
The probes never made skin contact, and did not again after a second deployment, its use was ineffective, Jones wrote in the report.
Jones was able to pull Williams out of the car and eventually subdued and cuffed him on the ground, after he used his shoulder to hit him in the chest, Jones stated.
Williams told the officers he had two guns in his waistband, a loaded Smith and Wesson and a loaded single action Ruger, both with 357 Magnum cartridges, according to the report. The Smith and Wesson was determined to have been stolen from Ann Arbor, Mich.
Emergency responders examined Williams before he was taken to the jail.

rfox@tribtoday.com


Pregnant woman assaulted

Pregnant woman assaulted,
boyfriend arrested on domestic violence charges

By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

WARREN ä William H. Davis, 29, pleaded not guilty Thursday to a charge of domestic violence in Warren Municipal Court.
Davisá pregnant girlfriend called police to their 1417 Front St. S.W. home Wednesday afternoon to report he had pushed her to ground, dragged her around on the floor and wouldnát let her take her 8-month-old baby with her when she left to call police at a neighbor's house, according to a police report.
Davis is being held at the county jail in lieu of $15,000 bond, and an order of protection for Emily Burr against Davis has been issued, according to court documents.
Burr told police the two had been arguing all day, she said when she slammed a door Davis became enraged and pushed her to the floor. When she got up and sat down, Burr stated, he grabbed by the ankles and pulled her to the floor, dragging her until her pants came off. Burr said she got up and tried to gather some things for herself and children to leave the home, when Davis refused to give her their 8-month-old baby or her cell phone. Burr, the officer wrote, has sole custody of the infant.Davis yelled at her to leave the house and then locked her and an older child out, according to the report.
Davis refused to answer the door for officers, but they did find the door unlocked after knocking for several minutes. They found Davis inside, holding the little boy. He initially refused to put the baby down, but did eventually and was taken into custody, officers reported.
Davis told police Burr had hit him and that he had pushed her in response, in an effort to get away from her.
Burr refused medical attention.
rfox@tribtoday.com


Marie Belcastro's daughter's 911 call

Most of the 911 call to Niles police from Marie R. Belcastroás daughter, who found Belcastro inside her Cherry Avenue, Niles, home on Tuesday. The call lasts 1 minute 20 seconds.
Police dispatcher: â911, whatás your emergency?ã
Caller: âIám at 509 Cherry St., Niles. Iám Marie Belcastroás daughter. I just walked into her house and I finally found her. She looks like sheás all smashed (unintelligible). Thereás blood in every room, it looks like her house was ransacked. I need, I donát know what I need.ã
Police dispatcher: âHow old is she?ã
Caller: âHow old is she?
Police dispatcher: âYeah.ã
Caller: âShe was 94. I think sheás dead. She looks, sheás in a twisted, sheás twisted in here in the bedroom.ã
Police dispatcher: âOK, and what, youáre at 509 Cherry?ã
Caller: âYeah, and I saw an ambulance when I walked in and saw all kind of stuff, an ambulance one block above, so I ran up there and I said, àI need someone.á I thought maybe they went to the wrong place and maybe she called them, but I think somebody came in, I know somebody came in here (unintelligible). I need people.ã
Police dispatcher: âAn ambulance is on their way over there and so is an officer.ã


911 tape, LaRosa's Niles police history

  âMother always justifies her sonás actions instead of making him take responsibility,ã Niles police officer Mike Biddlestone wrote in a report last year regarding 15-year-old Jacob LaRosa, charged with aggravated murder in the death of 94-year-old Marie Belcastro.

By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

NILES ä Police here on Thursday released reports that indicate the 15-year-old boy accused of beating an elderly woman to death Tuesday has had multiple run-ins with law enforcement.
Trumbull County Coronerás Office ruled Thursday that 94-year-old Marie R. Belcastroás death was a homicide, a result of a blow to the head.
In a 911 recording also released Thursday, Belcastroás distraught daughter can be heard describing the scene at her motherás âransackedã 509 Cherry Ave. home, after arriving to find âblood in every roomã and furniture âthrown all over.ã
She said her mother looked âall smashedã and that she found her mother âtwistedã in the bedroom.
A âblunt objectã is listed as the weapon on a police incident report.
The incident report states Belcastro was found on the bedroom floor, âbloodied and deceased,ã just after 5:30 p.m. At 5:55 p.m., officers told St. Joseph Warren Hospital to hold LaRosa. He had been transported there, intoxicated and vomiting, witnesses said, after being discovered near the scene of the murder shortly before Belcastroás body was found.
LaRosa, 502 Cherry Ave., is being held at the Juvenile Justice Center and has been charged with aggravated murder. Witnesses have said Belcastro paid LaRosa to do lawn work in the past.
Prosecutor Dennis Watkins said the case should be transferred from family court into the Trumbull County Common Pleas Court, where LaRosa can be tried as an adult, and prosecutors will be taking the proper legal steps to make that happen.
LaRosaás history with Niles police starts in September, 2013, the first time his mother, Megan Lucariello, reported he left and wouldnát come home, he was 14 at th time. The most recent report regarding LaRosa in February this year, before Belcastroás murder, was similar in content, when his mother asked officers to help her locate him around 1 a.m.
On Aug. 26, LaRosa was charged with receiving stolen property after officer Mike Biddlestone, who responded to six out of the 19 calls involving LaRosa, discovered him with a 76-year-old manás lawn mower, according to the report. The mower had been reported stolen from 814 Griffin Ave.
âI immediately recognized the male described (by the victim of the theft),ã Biddlestone stated. âThe juvenile has been involved in numerous, similar incidents in his neighborhood.ã
Biddlestone wrote in the report that LaRosaás mother said the boy was on house arrest, but, âhe comes and goes as he pleases.ã
âI told her she is ultimately responsible for him and needs to report such disobedient behavior to his probation officer,ã Biddlestone wrote in the report.
On Aug. 1, officers found a lawn mower that had been reported stolen from 322 Lafayette Ave. in LaRosaás driveway, but he was not charged. Lawn mowers in both incidents were returned.
In July, a report states, LaRosa was caught by neighbors throwing rocks at cars, he was not charged, but officers had to settle an argument between the Lucariello and the neighbor.
âMother has been told numerous times how to file and follow up properly with TC JJC, however, appears to fail to do so,ã Biddlestone wrote in the report. âStepfather of Jacob wanted to know if at any point she (Lucariello) should be held liable (for LaRosaás actions).ã
Biddlestone told the family that any of his guardians might be liable, but his probation officer should be consulted to find a way to change his behavior.
âMother always justifies her sonás actions instead of making him take responsibility,ã Biddlestone wrote.
On June 24, an employee at the Vienna Avenue Giant Eagle told police LaRosa was on video rifling through cars. Although LaRosa was not charged, Officer Dan Atkins stated that he faxed a copy of the incident report to Sherry Calloway, his probation officer. LaRosa claimed a boy forced him to take money from the vehicle. In October of 2013, LaRosa was caught shoplifting at the same grocery store, according to a report, and Giant Eagle told officers they would press charges, but it is unclear if they did.
Jackie Franks, a former neighbor of LaRosaás, said she had caught him stealing from a convenience store where she worked at least three times, but never filed reports.
On June 2, LaRosa was arrested for assaulting his sister. Reports state he threw a glass candle at the 7-year-old, hitting her in the head and causing a 3-inch cut that left âblood covering her face and nose.ã LaRosa had fled the scene but was picked up by officers near Niles Intermediate School after reports of kids going through a dumpster there.
In May, police responded to the school for an alleged assault LaRosa was the victim of on the basketball court, no one was charged in the incident, LaRosa claimed the other boy was the aggressor and no statements or reports with more information on the altercation were provided by police.
There are three reports from LaRosaás mother and stepfather alleging he stole equipment from their garage and electronic devices in January and March of last year.
In September of 2013, Edward LaRosa, Jacobás father, filed a police report stating his son had been forced by a one-armed 60-year-old man to smoke marijuana and take valium.
LaRosa lives with his mother, siblings and stepfather, Randall Lucariello. His father has an address on Townsend Avenue in Youngstown. All three of the phone numbers listed in police reports for LaRosaás guardians have been disconnected.

rfox@tribtoday.com



Accused Pit Stop shooters bound over

By RENEE FOX
Tribune Chronicle

WARREN ä Robert Burkey, 23, and Juchard Duncan, 25, the men accused of firing three shots at the Pit Stop last month, appeared in Warren Municipal Court Thursday for a pre-trial hearing before Judge Terry Ivanchak.
Burkey, 1641 Mayfield Ave. in Youngstown, was bound over to the Trumbull County Common Pleas Court on a felony charge of having weapons under disability, a charge of felonious assault was dismissed, as were some misdemeanor offenses associated with the incident. Burkey remains in county jail.
Duncan, 2263 Brier St. S.E. in Warren, also held at the jail, was bound over on a felony failure to comply with the orders of a police officer charge. Another felony charge, receiving stolen property, and a misdemeanor resisting arrest charge were dismissed.
Lt. Martin Gargas was on patrol March 24 when he saw a man get out of a vehicle, fire three shots at the gas station and convenience store, and get back in the vehicle, which took off.
Gargas gave chase. The two men abandoned the vehicle, which was determined to be stolen, on Thomas Road S.E. and ran about 150 yards into the woods.
Police officers descended upon the area and found them hiding inside an abandoned factory, the former Design Coating Systems, at 1500 Milton St.

rfox@tribtoday.com